July 25, 2015

(217) 3 plays (and 2 authors?) with Henry V - Shakespeare a plagiarist?

T H E    P R O B L E M S

with the Henry V plays

1     FVH


2 CHV
             3 LHV
1.  The Famous Victories  1594(1598)  of  Henry V (F V H)    [A n o n y m u s]
2.  Q1 1600 The Chronicle History    of  Henry V (C H V)      [S h a k e s p e a r e]        
3 FF 1623 The Life of   Henry V (L H V)                                [S h a ke  s p e a r e]
                                                                                                                      

3 Shakespeare's Folio play "The Life of Henry the Fift (LHV-1623 FF)" first appeared as a much
2 smaller Quarto "The Chronicle History of Henry V (C H V-1600- Q1).
_———————

Prof. Bate in his Shakespeare MOOC course 2014 (lesson 4) dealt with "The War play Henry V". He explained how L H V relates to the play "The Famous Victories of Henry the Fifth" (FVH-1598), a play of an anonymous author registered 1594 in the Stationers' Register (within the year of Marlowe's disappearance) but printed only 4 years later. (Prof.Bate:"...to be honest, [FVH] its not very good"! )

V H F bears distinctive similarities to L H V concerning title, title emblem and design, 15 plot elements have been identified that occur in both the anonymous play V H F and in the Henry trilogy. (Bate: "...Shakespeare later in the 1590ies set about reworking the story of F V H". How does Bate know?)

Leaving aside a closer relationship between FVH and L H V   Prof. Bate should have given us a more plausible explanation...--->

--> a) Why Shakespeare was such a plagiarist and has "stolen" title, emblem and design from the unnamed author of FVH, 

--> b) Who may have been the anonymous author 1594 of FVH and 

--> c) when the extensive Changes, Additions and Augmentations of LHV 
    (compared to Q1 Q2 Q3 in CHV) were made?

Isn't there a better, simpler and more coherent theory for this bizzare and strange situation of 
FVH,   C H V and   L H V ,

clearly related to the Authorship Problem?


---------------------------------------
VIDEOS – Complete Video Archive:
OPEN  —>   Heading-->  Home -->Videos -- Shorts  -- Posts
                                                                   ->Popular