4 Apr 2015

(97) Authorship debates! - Annual rituals! Eternal recurrence of the same ??


Paul Edmondson‘s stranded Conclusions!



3 notable statements of Paul Edmonson




 Edmondson      Dobson         Wells                      Emmerich           Beauclerk            Leahy

Paul Edmondson on  a →"Shakespeare Oxford Authorship debate" , organized by the English Speaking Union  (ESU) June 2011  on the occasion of Emmerichs film "Anonymous" among other things made 3 notable statements which have etched unforgettably in my mind:

1) Edmondson "Any actor will tell you that Christopher Marlowe's´mighty line is that of a different writer:[compared to Shakespeare] "
How could he reach such a "stranded" conclusion ? There are only a few actors who ever played Marlowe. Why did he elevate "any actor" to a literary key witness?  Experts agree that "Edward II" , or "Hero & Leander" (Marlowe)   and "Richard III" or "Venus &Adonis" (Shakespeare) are virtually identical in terms of substance, style and artistic Level.

2) Edmondson:  "The Suggestion that de Vere was able to release 14 plays after his death in 1604 including one coauthored with Thomas Middleton and another coauthored with John Wilkins and 3 coauthored with John Fletcher beggars belief"
Does  Edmondson really beleive that the author of Hamlet was a "teamplayer" at all ?

3) Edmondson "Perhaps there is material for a Holywood Sequel showing that Shakespeares collaborators were also front men for aristocratic geniuses.  

"Edmondson mocked at the  Oxfordian idea of Shakespeare beeing a frontman, by adding additional "established" poets as frontmen (Middleton ,Wilkins, Fletcher).

He has  not yet noticed, that his suggestion - according to  the advanced Marlowe.   Theory- approaches the historic truth!
5th Edition January 2016